On May 25, 2012 I walked into the Swedish Cancer Institute for the very first time. I had learned of my breast cancer diagnosis the day before and I was there along with my husband and my friend, Nancy, for a consultation with the physician who would perform my first three breast surgeries, two lumpectomies followed by a right-side mastectomy.
I remember a few things from that morning. One of the strongest memories I have is a feeling of surprise when the physician’s assistance asked me to step on the scale for my weight. To me the word, “consultation” meant “talking” and that’s what I had expected. To relieve the tension, I joked, “I have to get weighed? That’s worse than having cancer!”
Granted, I was joking but as you know jokes come from some where. Who among us have not felt defined by a number, our age, our weight, our grades, or our annual income? Most of us have at one point or another, defined ourselves this way. And the definitions can come with a great deal of negative judgment.
As a researcher and clinician, I also know that numbers can serve as useful data. There are two properties of measures that are important in yielding meaningful data. One property is the validity of the measurement tool. A valid measure actually measures what it is intended to. When I stand in front of the ruler on the wall of the doctor’s office, the ruler actually measures my height. However, not all measures are valid at all. For example, when I walk out the door in the winter time it sometimes “smells like snow”, meaning that I am detecting something in the air that to me is the odor of snow. This predictive measure, as it turns out is not very accurate. It is not a valid measure of snow potential. I don’t even know what I am perceiving that makes it “smell like snow”.
The scale can be a useful measure. But is it a valid measure of value as a person? No, a scale, a good one anyway, is a valid measure of weight. It is not a valid measure of general health because general health is not defined by just body weight. It can be a factor in health but it is not all-encompassing.
Just like people say, “age is just a number” it can be tempting to deal with the judgment that comes with weight and just conclude that “weight is just a number”. This implies that it has no meaning or usefulness.
My weight has been creeping up steadily over the past year. I am almost to the weight that I was before I lost my last 40 pounds, nearly 4 years ago. Based on the way my clothes fit, I can tell that I am not as large as I was at that time, I assume because I am more muscular than I was then. But I am noticing that I am able to wear less and less of my wardrobe. I’ve gotten noticeably larger.
I did a great deal of work on my body image when I was going through cancer treatment. I learned to appreciate what my body does for me. I have a positive body image. I feel strong. But I also know that having had estrogen and progesterone responsive breast cancer that it is important that I maintain a healthy amount of body fat. Right now, it is clear that I have too much.
I’ve known this for awhile. Behavior change, developing new habits, and re-developing old good habits is really difficult. Every once in awhile I get to a point at which it seems harder to continue doing what I am doing than motivating myself to change. Last week, I asked my husband to start going to Weight Watchers meetings with me. I had been doing their online program on and off for the last 10 years. Since I have not been following the program for awhile, I thought going back to meetings might be helpful. My husband has been having a lot of back problems and I thought that his losing weight might be a positive for him, as well.
He agreed. We went to our first meeting the next day, which was last Sunday. Three days down, many to go.
Measures can help guide me to follow my intentions and commitments in life. They don’t define my worth.
I went to Weight Watchers years ago and enjoyed the experience. Hope you achieve your goals.
Thanks, Yvonne! So far, so good!
Hi Elizabeth,
I really love this post. Since cancer, I have struggled with my weight. And now after my dad’s death, I have been eating way too much comfort food and I am already gaining back the ten pounds I had FINALLY lost. (And I need to lose more) I am trying hard to be kind to myself, especially during this time, but still… And another story similar to yours… when I recently saw a dermatologist, I was so relieved to not get weighed. How dumb is that? I actually made some stupid comment about at least not having to step on a scale at this appt. I feel I have a solid self image too, but gosh, the weight thing keeps bugging me. Anyway, great post. thank you for writing it. One more thing, I went to WW several times in years past, might have to think about rejoining at some point. Not yet though. still want that comfort food! Lord, I’m my own worst enemy! Good luck to you! And you, my dear, are a beautiful soul no matter what the scale says. I know that’s cliche, but it’s also true in your case, my friend. Forgive my ramble…
Nancy, I’m glad this post resounded with you. Grief and stress wreak havoc with my mindful eating either because I’m not paying attention or because I feel entitled to eat un-healthfully because I “deserve” it.
The program is going well so far. I’ve lost 7 pounds in 2 weeks. I tend to lose at a higher rate at first and then more slowly. They changed the plan last September, including the response to weigh-in’s. (I noticed that first online. There are no comments with a weight gain. And in person, they say nothing or little about losing weight.) I like the new plan and I like the meeting leader.
[…] my own weight steadily climb over the past three years, I really appreciated reading Elizabeth‘s sensible, non-judgemental approach to weight in her latest […]
Way to go! I think it’s time for me to see WW as well. I’ve gained 15 lbs since my cancer treatment and I can really feel it. My frame can handle it but I’m not so sure about the mind.
Good luck, Nelson!